Putting Me Through The Wringer
When I got home from the day job yesterday, lying on the coffee table was an envelope waiting for me to open it. Calling for me to open it. Screaming at me, really.
It was a copy of the short story "Lost and Found" that yesterday I told you had been taken by a bestselling mystery author friend of mine to be read and critiqued.
When he took it, he warned me he would "tell it like it is," He didn't want to create any bad feelings in our friendship. I told him I understood. I told him I wanted that critical eye telling me what I was doing wrong and what (if anything) I had done right. He told me that if he didn't make a comment on a sentence or paragraph, that meant he liked it. He said he'd make comments to help me improve the story otherwise.
I ripped open the envelope and sat down to both read the story and his comments. There was a Post-It note stuck to the front page- "I put you through the ringer (sic.) buddy- hope it helps!"
I was prepared for absolute devastation, but as it turns out, I didn't need to be. He made a lot of comments, ninety percent of which I think can only make the story better. There are some that made me think I might have to rework the underlying plot and reset the time line. There are even a few that are forcing me to do what I didn't want to- get rid of the first sentences and paragraphs that I wrote which were the basis of the story.
Click here to see the story and the editorial critique.
It was interesting and eye opening to get this perspective from someone who has been there and understands what it takes to make a story interesting. Now, if you'll excuse me, I must get back to work, as it seems I have a lot of work to do.



"Lost and Found," the short story I've been working on and sharing here with you has officially been placed on the back burner as I've sent manuscript copies to a couple of friends who have graciously volunteered to read and critique it for me (Thanks Eric and Brandon!).